Midlevel court reverses judge, rules NY state parks can enforce ban on outdoor smoking


We also have more stories about:
(click the phrases to see a list)




ALBANY, New York — A ban on outdoor smoking in New York parks was upheld Wednesday by a midlevel court, reversing a judge and dismissing a challenge filed by a smokers' rights group.

The Appellate Division, ruling unanimously, said the ban was consistent with the mission of the Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation — "to allow all patrons to enjoy the fresh air and natural beauty of its outdoor facilities."

The five justices concluded the agency didn't usurp the Legislature's authority with regulations that banned smoking at state parks in New York City and at designated areas at other parks around the state. The panel acknowledged there's no specific legislative directive to restrict park smoking outdoors.

They noted the Legislature has prohibited smoking at indoor public spaces and expressed "its determination that tobacco smoke, including secondhand smoke, is hazardous to one's health."

"Furthermore, the record does not indicate that the designation of no smoking areas continues to be the subject of great public debate," Justice Karen Peters wrote. "In fact, 91 percent of the comments that respondents received on this rule were favorable and many commenters expressed their desire that smoking be banned outright in all state parks."

The rules established no-smoking areas in February 2013 at various parks statewide, including popular beaches and all nine state parks within New York City. The city has a separate outdoor smoking ban for its parks and beaches, which had City Council backing and wasn't challenged in this lawsuit.

Judge George Ceresia ruled last fall that state parks officials exceeded their authority, ordering they stop enforcing the outdoor ban and take down the signs. He noted that the Legislature had previously considered but failed to enact an outdoor ban.

The parks office said Wednesday's "decisive" court ruling upheld a common-sense policy to let visitors enjoy the outdoors without being bothered by secondhand smoke and keeping parks healthy places for families. It has posted online its list of no-smoking areas.

Edward Paltzik, attorney for NYC Citizens Lobbying Against Smoker Harassment, said he's disappointed Ceresia's ruling was overturned and will encourage his client to appeal. He had called the previous ruling "a vindication of individual rights in the face of government overreach."

He said the court "minimized the importance" of lawmakers' repeated failure to pass legislation and overlooked the park agency's rule that would allow it to ban smoking entirely, though it only applies now to about 5 percent of state parkland.


State park no-smoking areas:


All content copyright ©2015 Daily Journal, a division of Home News Enterprises unless otherwise noted.
All rights reserved. Click here to read our privacy policy.